Episode 20
Oppression, Poverty and Lament: An Interview with a World Vision Pastor
Show Notes
Pastor Carolyn Poteet, a friend of the Howards who now serves an Evangelical Presbyterian church in Pittsburgh, spent most of the 1990s working with World Vision in communities shaped by war, poverty, and displacement. She shares what she learned sitting at the feet of believers in places like Mozambique and Angola: the difference between physical and spiritual poverty, the reality of oppressive spiritual strongholds that can linger over a region for generations, and a remarkable story of a village that turned to Christ when the tree it worshiped fell. The conversation then turns to lament, a practice the American church often skips. Carolyn explains how the Psalms give us permission to bring raw complaint to God, how every lament has a turn toward remembering His faithfulness, and how trusting God when nothing goes according to plan becomes its own kind of adventure.
In This Episode
- Serving among the global church teaches us to sit at the feet of believers whose faith is lived with resilience and depth.
- Physical poverty and spiritual poverty are not the same; communities with little can still carry beauty and hope.
- Some places carry generational spiritual oppression, but God is greater than any territorial power.
- Ministry must care for both body and soul; people often cannot hear the gospel while they are starving.
- Listening for where the Holy Spirit is groaning helps us bring good news in a way people can receive.
- Lament is honest prayer; God welcomes our groaning, and we do not have to get it together before coming to Him.
- Every psalm of lament has a turn: remembering God's faithfulness even before the feelings change.
Going Deeper — Discussion Questions
- Carolyn says her time overseas showed her she needed to sit at people's feet. Who in the global church or in your community has taught you something about faith?
- How would you describe the difference between physical poverty and spiritual poverty? Where do you see each around you?
- What do you make of the idea that places can carry spiritual oppression? How does the story of the fallen tree encourage you?
- Why do you think the church in the West tends to skip lament and move straight to Easter Sunday?
- Have you ever written or prayed an honest complaint to God? What happened as you prayed?
- What helps you remember God's faithfulness when you are still sad or angry?
- Carolyn's brother says it is not an adventure until things don't go according to plan. Where do you need to trust God in a situation that is not going as planned?
Full Transcript
▸Hide transcript · 54 min episode
0:03Introduction: Meeting Carolyn
Welcome to Between Heaven and Earth. We're your hosts, Justin and Amy Howard. And together, we lead a mission agency right here in beautiful New England. We are thrilled that you've joined us. In each episode, we'll explore what it means to follow Jesus by bringing heaven and earth together in your family and community. Our goal is to empower you to thrive in the collision of kingdoms and courageously join with Jesus in his great project of healing and restoration. This podcast is brought to you by Encounter Culture Mission Collaborative, dedicated to working with ordinary followers of Jesus to mend, make, and multiply disciples right where they are. Let's dive in. Well, welcome back. Welcome back to Between Heaven and Earth. These are podcasts where we explore the stories of transformation, healing, and formation through the Ministry of Encounter Culture. These podcasts are made possible by the generous sponsorship of you, our listeners. If you've been blessed by what you've been hearing and would like to help continue to make these podcasts available,
You can partner with us financially by donating using the link below or by visiting us at encounterculturene.com and clicking on the drop-down donate. So today I am joined by a personal friend and really remarkable human, Carolyn Petit. Did I say that right? Petit? Petit? Petit? Petit. We gotta nix that bit. Cause I said it right the first time. I get nervous. She is a seasoned leader and a pastor, currently serving an Evangelical Presbyterian church in Pittsburgh, and like I said, a personal friend. But long before she stepped into parish ministry, Carolyn spent nearly a decade, between I think you said 1991 and 1999, working around the globe as an international program developer, development officer for world vision. Her work
Took her into the heart of communities affected by war, poverty, and displacement, places where faith is lived with remarkable resilience and depth. We were talking about this earlier, that it just exercises a different kind of muscle. And I really look forward to hearing kind of your take on what you experienced. Along the way, Carolyn encountered forms of suffering and strength. And spirituality that challenged and expanded her Western assumptions about life, ministry, and the gospel. So, in our conversation today, she shares how her experience in the global church shaped her theology, maybe deepened her compassion and informed the way she now really thinks about church, thinks about God, thinks about what her job is. And I think this story really invites us to consider what it means to follow Christ globally.
And also just into difficult places. So let's dive in. Welcome, Carolyn. Thanks. It's awesome to be here. It's So good to have you here. Carolyn's been haunting our house here in New Hampshire for the last, I don't know, a week or so. Right and I'm on sabbatical actually, so I got roped into this, but I'm glad to be able to do it. I'm also glad to be able to spend some time with chickens and goats and sourdough bread and the beautiful New Hampshire country countryside. Whatever it takes. And today we're making you sing for your supper. Man. Well, it's so good to have you. I would love just before we get into the real nitty gritty stuff, you have traveled in so many countries. My kids were loving hearing about all the places that you've been and some of the things that you've seen. Okay, do you have a favorite dish or food that you still crave from your time overseas?
Well, t two came to mind when you mentioned that. One, when I was in Mozambique, it's very Brazilian food. Fijuada is this bean stew thing that I think about. But everything that they served had sauces on it. And it was so good. And so now, like I do not like dry meat. I do I don't like dry rice. I want some kind of saucy thing to go with stuff. So that's one thing. The other one is and you've lived in Austria, so you probably know this one. Apple strudel with vanilla cream sauce. Come on. I mean there's nothing better on the planet. I literally one time was served at like an Airbnb, was served chicken broth for dinner and a huge piece of apple strudel for dessert. Yeah, absolutely.
Really nothing like that. You were like, These are my people. The content comes with dessert. And that's fantastic. So what another one, what's something that you always packed in your suitcase, no matter where you were going? Yeah. Frequently for a long time I would pack peanut butter because I really love peanut butter. I would have people import that to Austria for me. But somebody said to who was a seasoned travel traveler when I first started, pack something that smells good that reminds you of home or something that's a great idea. So, you know, it might be lavender soap or lotion or something like that. So that literally is on my packing list. I'm about to leave for England for six weeks and
Idea. On my packing list it says something that smells good. Wow. A wise traveler once told me, never leave home without a decent instant coffee. Like some in your toiletry bag or whatever. 'cause where you're going, I mean inst not like instant coffee's amazing, but it is better than not it's better than no coffee. Right. I will tell you, almost every s like strawberry jam on toast is one of my comfort foods. And almost every single country I've ever been in has strawberry jam and b good bread. Wow. So that was one I could find on my Such a pain to grow. That's amazing that they're so global. I mean, like Azerbaijan I found strawberry jams. Okay.
6:21A Decade with World Vision
That's wonderful. All right. Well, let's dive into some of the more intense questions here. So you spent nearly a decade working with world vision in some of the most challenging parts of the world. Can you take us back to that time? Take us back to what drew you into it, and maybe kind of, yeah, give us, give us a backdrop. Yeah. It was totally a God idea. It was not my idea. I was a political science, international relations major in college and, you know, thought I would go into either foreign service or the government and I couldn't get a job. I moved to DC, thought everything would be wonderful, couldn't find a job. And literally a temp job opened up at World Vision and I the office manager went to my church and she said, Hey, would you be willing to temp for us for a little while? And within the first couple of days, I'm like, These are my people, this is why I
Do because it just had so much meaning to it. Like, you know, even when you were just doing basic office stuff, making copies or whatever, it was helping people who were facing hardship overseas. And that was so rich. And so they found out that I could write and then they taught me how to write grant proposals. And so that led to me being able to travel and go to different country sites and to be able to work. So I've saw some really rough places. I was one of the only For I was based in Mozambique for a little while and Austria for a couple of years. But then the rest of the time I was in the States but traveling to these places. And I was one of the only stateside based people that had year round war insurance because your new normal insurance does not cover things that happen to you in war. And I was in so many war zones so often that they I had to have war insurance.
And is that like a local insurance that's you know, based it you know, in your health care? It was a special separate thing. And like it would pay for evacuations and emergency medical care and crazy stuff. And a friend of mine had to use it one time when he got sick in the middle of the Congo and they had lifelite them out. Wow. So yeah, it's it was that kind of thing. But it like you said, even in the midst of all of that, I saw God so many different places. One the first trip I ever went on, I was My first stop was in Ethiopia and these were people that had gone through the you know the Ethio Ethiopian famine was only ten years before that, eight years before that. And some of the people on staff there were the most faithful Christians I've ever met in my life. Wow. And you know, they would work all day, every day. And I was right there with them, you know, trying to do all the work. But by the end of the day on Friday, I was just exhausted and wanted to go back to my hotel and sleep. And they would have
An all night prayer meeting at the end of the week. And I'm like, I am such a wimp. So I mean, that must have made an impression on you as a twenty something. I mean, you're a young adult. Why what did that speak to you even then? Yeah. I mean, immediately it was you know, I think Americans kind of think we've got it together, we need to help the rest of the world. And when I was there, I'm like, holy cow, these are giants of the faith and I need to learn from them. Yeah. And that really instantly changed my posture toward the people that I worked with. Because you know, yes, I had some skills that they needed and that I could contribute, but in terms of the richness of faith, it was a really humbling experience. And
Just made me realize that I needed to sit at people's feet. Yeah. That you also had a lot to learn. Yeah. Well, we're hoping to pillage some of that, what some of the wisdom that you gleaned while you were traveling, while we're talking together. What so what were what were some of the regions that made the deepest impression on you? Yeah. What was it? And maybe and maybe, I mean, if I could get the stor I mean, I'm probably skipping ahead, but the Baobab. Yeah, right. It's such a great story. Yeah. That so many different regions had a huge impact on me. And one of the reasons why I'm a pastor now, and I'm really skipping ahead now, but I would go into these places with huge physical poverty, but there was spiritual wealth that I like the Ethiopian staff. That really spoke to me a lot. Other places, you and I talked some about Eastern Europe and how.
10:46Physical and Spiritual Poverty
There was physical poverty and spiritual poverty there. Say more about that because that was that was really eye-opening for me when you were kind of really clearly drawing those lines. Can you just describe a little bit? Yeah, I mean I was in a lot of post communist countries or quasi com communist countries, whatever they are. I moved to Eastern Europe shortly after the Soviet Union broke up and I traveled in a bunch of different Azerbaijan, Georgia, Armenia, Romania, s Bosnia, places like that. And like for instance, Romania, it Some of you may remember the Romanian orphan stories. A hundred thousand kids and orphanages in Romania. And I went to visit some of those. And you know, so here you have the ultimate poverty of these children, most of whom had at least one living parent. Wow. But they had been told that the government could raise their kids better than they could. And so the parents let go of these kids and put them in institutions. And I have never been in such spiritual poverty in my life.
I mean these kids, I went into one room that was like the size of your living room, 30 kids in it, and not a sound. They were sitting on mattresses on the floor, nobody was talking, nobody was playing, nobody was interacting. And it was just this, you know, these are human beings made in the image of God, and there was no light. There was no and that to me was one of the darkest places that just stays with me. Like the kids didn't even know how to smile. In Africa, no matter where I went, the kids would always come up to me with a smile and Saying they had some they had some sp in some of the places that you went, they were physically poor. You saw physical poverty, but there was still maybe a sense of hope. There was a richness of their own spiritual heritage, their connection with God, communion.
It was love. Like one image I still have in my head, I was in a you know, you see on the TV commercials the feeding centers where people are literally starving to death and you have you know, the flies in the kids' eyes and stuff. I've been in places like that and it really is that bad. But there was one time I was in one of these feeding centers that was targeting infants and children, you know, little bitty ones who were severely malnour nourished and would have died if they had not had this was an Angola. And there was a mom with her baby, you know, she's just skin and bones, and this baby is just barely making it. And yet she was playing peekaboo with her baby. Wow. And that just struck me that there was still this love that, you know, it was like the Romanian orphans didn't have that because their parents had let go of them. But there's this love of community and family in Africa that some of the places that I was in.
It's just beautiful. And you know, if a bunch of Americans had been in that situation, that probably wouldn't have been Might have might have been a really different experience. Right, exactly. But to see that was like hopeful that she still wanted she hadn't given up on her child. She still wanted to pour into that child. Yeah. I remember thinking that for a season of time we lived in an area that was very close to a r a Native American reservation. And there was a just a ton in our town and also in the reservation, but pr more pronouncely in the reservation. And there was a ton of poverty in both places. I where we lived personally and across the river.
Both places were really poor. But the spiritual poverty across was what really struck me. And the way that it the way that it was highlighted to me, I didn't actually really notice it until I traveled to Croatia. And when we were out kind of in a really pretty impoverished part of Croatia, not the kind of poverty that you are describing, but still very hand-to-mouth. Right. You know, cinder block houses. But every house had Sunflowers and a rose bush and a pear tree with which they made rachia. Which is a form of schnapps, if you're wondering. Like it's like a distilled but it's like a brandy. Yeah. But there was this sense of like beauty. Right. Like roses are really unnecessary. Right. So there was just this sense of long term investment in the land, beautifying the environment. There was still something of belonging and personhood there. We talk a lot about, you know, what does the kingdom of God look like? And where are some places where you kind of catch little glimpses, even if Jesus' name isn't
Pronounced on it yet. Like what, you know, where is the, you know, where is God at work in these places? Where are evident signs of life? And to me, that really struck me because where we had been living on our side of the island and on the other side of the excuse me, on our side of the river and the other side of the river, what I particularly noticed on the reservation island was the lack of planted things. I remember going in the spring To do a stations of the cross with some of the there was a little community of sisters who just kept a just a little outpost on this island reservation and there wasn't one flower there no one there where I could see in all we walked around the whole town praying stations at the cross and
Wow. I didn't see one sign of in six months this is gonna be worth seeing. So I'm gonna plant it now. There was just such a deep maybe hopelessness. Right. Maybe yeah. That was the difference. Right. It was both. It was both physical poverty and a something deeper, something more And that can definitely be a spiritual presence. We talked a little bit about like a territorial spirit, like a spirit that is h in that place that is sucking the hope out of it. And sucking the life out of it. And sometimes like even if you did plant something, it might die because of that oppression. Yes. That's just in the air.
17:21Spiritual Strongholds in Angola
And you were saying to me, or skipping ahead a little bit, let's just go for it. You were saying to me, one of the maybe the things that you could see easier when you were out of your own environment was the way that different regions experienced different things. Right. Yeah. I was mentioning a story. I was in Angola, if those of you who are Gen X and older, remember that when Princess Diana did her famous walk through a minefield. Well, I was in Angola about the same time, and a little before her she was there. So some of these places were just horrible. There were more landmines in Angola than people. Wow. Like there were three million people and five million landmines or something crazy like that. Yeah.
So we were our water guy was driving me around, the guy that would figure out where to dig a well and latrines and things like that. So he was driving me around showing us some of the project sites. And he said there's this one place that we cannot get people to cooperate. And by cooperate, I mean we wanted to give them food if they would dig latrines and a well. It seemed like a pretty project. Yeah. They would get food, it would help them their There's a lot of malnutrition in the area. But he couldn't figure out why. And he's as we turned off the main road into this little track that was completely overgrown, he said, By the way, this is the first capital of Angola. And I'm like, What are you talking about? Because it was the middle of nowhere. We were, you know, hours away from the coast. I couldn't understand it. Why Right. Yeah. And so we driving through the bush, you know, the
This be the capital. Vehicles just being brushed on both sides of with trees and things. And we then we break out into this clearing and there are all these ruins of Portuguese buildings all around. And it was actually kind of on a on a bluff above the river. So the river was the Kwanzaa River. If you hear about celebrating Kwanzaa, is that's where the word comes from. And it was where the Portuguese had built their first settlement in Angola. And he Told me what the buildings were and like that's the mayor's house and that's the town hall and that's the slave market. Whoa. And there it was creepy. There were goats on top of the slave market, which somehow made it even creepier. And then there was a church and it was the oldest continually operating church, I think, in so sub-Saharan Africa. It was crazy. And there were children in the church that came out singing, which
It was like if like a movie scene. Yeah. It was so bizarre to have Contract. How do you even ingest those various things on Absolutely. Exactly. And I did a little bit more reading about that area. And what would happen that was a the chiefdom in that area was very powerful. So anytime that they would fight somebody, they would take the people that they captured from another tribe and they'd sell them to the Portuguese, who would then sell them across the Atlantic in Brazil for the plantations in Brazil and slave as a slaves. So that was the market, that was the business. And so that what I realized, and then they the our water guy took me down to meet some of the people that didn't want to work. And so we talked to them and asked, you know, why don't you want to do this? And their kids were a all around them and they were clearly malnourished. There are certain signs that you can see, like their hair is orange and their bellies are distended, but their arms are, you know, tiny. And so the kids are all malnourished. And we're asking the parents, why don't you want to work for food? And they
They kind of mocked us and said, Well, we just want to sit around and drink palm wine. You know, like we don't care. And what occurred to me was that it was the same spirit of exploitation that had been there for five hundred years of like they don't care about their own people. And they're letting their kids just, you know, their lives be destroyed because they're only caring about themselves. And it was the same spirit. Kind of thing. And it w it was that was a just a really heavy place of that was the first time I ever really sensed that kind of territorial thing that was like, There's something deep here that's been here for generations.
We've come across that in different in different ways. I mean, I think there's such a deep biblical precedent for that, even though that might sound a little foreign to maybe Western ears. Right. But if you look at the churches in Revelation, there was a real sense that different places had different problems. Right. And that problems tended to be pervasive. And one of the really fascinating kind of asides that I've noticed over the years, not just me, but other people as well. Has been bird song. This is this is this is crazy. So in places where there's been mass an a an immense amount of suffering and death, like especially violence, it I there birds don't sing.
Interesting. It's the eerie kind of uncanny experience to be in a place with trees, with, you know, you walk a block away maybe and there are birds. I remember visiting ground zero, where the where the twin towers went down. Right. And years later, still no bird song. And we had walked from bird song in other parts of the city. And I was just aware, like, it's so neat that even in the midst of the city there are birds. No birds. I mean just an eerie silence. And I saw the opposite of it. We went up in a CC to visit where is to visit St. Francis Hermitage. Yeah. And you know that I don't know if you've ever been up at 4 AM. Well, that's what time it happens here in New England, but just as just before the sun comes up and all the birds wake up. And it's so loud that you have to talk louder to be heard if anyone else is actually awake during that time. It was like that.
Wow at noon. It was like that. You had to lift your voice to be heard over the birds. They were so loud. They were so loud. So yeah, so regions, areas. My gosh. Yeah, and I told you the story. My favorite story was a like God is bigger than that. God is bigger than the dysfunction, the pain, this even the sacrifice. And I was telling you a story. My f one of my favorite stories from World Vision Days, you know, some people wonder about like, is humanitarian aid enough? Is you know, you need to go in there with the gospel and that's more important. But sometimes it's a World Vision really believed in a holistic mentality.
It's a both hand it's a both hand. It's a both hand. Yeah, your body matters too. Yeah, right. And sometimes people can't hear you if they're starving. Yeah. You know, so feed them first and then share the words. But so this World Vision was trying to go into this area. I believe it was it was either Molly or Mauritanium in West Africa. And there was this village where they wanted to, you know, build a school and dig a well and those usual things, and they couldn't get the project to work. Nothing worked. They tried all the usual plans and everything just felt like it was. Running into a brick wall. And so they spent time praying about what was going on and is there a territorial something that's coming against them? And they tried everything, but they finally were like, you know, I maybe it's this tree. And there was I don't know if you've ever seen, you know, like the movie Madagascar or whatever. There's these huge trees. They're called Boabab trees and they're massive. And that in Africa they'll tell you it's they think it's the only tree that the devil made because they look like they're planted upside down.
25:21The Day the Tree Fell
So the tree limbs actually kind of look like roots. And so it looks like it's upside down. But these are like forty feet in circumference. I'm just huge trees. And there's there was a tree in this village that was really worshipped as the local god. It was the animistic religion that this tree is what's powerful. And so the world vision team was like, you know, everything else has not worked. Let's pray against the tree. Let just Try and let's see what happens. And so they got together and they stood around the tree and they prayed and prayed and prayed and prayed and prayed and looked up and nothing happened. Okay. And then like, well, let's try one more time. Prayed and prayed and prayed and prayed and prayed, looked up, nothing happened. They're like, Well, we might as well just go to bed, try again tomorrow and see what happens. So they wake up the next morning to the to the sound of people running and screaming. And they're like, What happened?
And they went out and followed everybody, and they were all gathered around this tree, 40 feet in circumference, and the tree had fallen over. Wow. And the chief turned to them and said, Who is your God? I want to know your God. And the whole village converted to Christianity because they saw that their local God did not have the power over the one true God. And it's just the such a great story because it's Yes, sometimes we feel so burdened and oppressed by these territorial spirits, but God's bigger than that. And, you know, he can tear down a forty foot circumference boabed tree. He can do anything we need we need to.
Yeah, and I love I just want to highlight in the telling of your story some of the trouble like they were looking to God to solve the problem. They weren't like going after the demonic. They weren't chasing down something. They were saying, God, you act and kind of unstick what's stuck. That I mean that it's fascinating to me that it Mm-hmm. It seems like it's easier to see when it's not your hometown. Right, absolutely. It seems like it might be a little easier to notice. Right. I c and sometimes we go kind of hunting where's the where's the devil in this situation or whatever. But w instead of like first need to start with God. Like, okay, God, what's going on here? What can I not see? Yeah. You know, what am I up against here? And how would you like me to deal with the
27:46Seeing the Bigger Picture
Yeah. And I'm here, so I'm being impacted by it. How do I gain a sort of a twenty thousand foot view? How do I how do I be a part of the heaven and earth conversation, not just sort of a part of the str the horizontal struggle? Right. Because the horizontal struggle was, you know, kind of it sounded like kind of impossible. Where it's just uphill. Like I just can't just no matter how hard I work here, this isn't happening. But I but it sounds like once they were able to kind of get out of that conversation, this isn't working, and ask the Lord, God, what's going on here? Maybe there's something bigger than us.
Yeah. And I find that that's just I one of the struggles that I think in perhaps in the West that we come up against is because we're so global in some ways and we're so national in others, sometimes I wonder if we're trying to address everybody else's stuff. Rather than waiting on the Lord for kind of the homegrown. Like what's nearby? What's my local struggle? I mean the churches in the book of Revelation were not that geographically removed. I mean I'm pretty sure geographically they'd all fit within the United States. A couple Texas. Probably within maybe not New Hampshire, but Right. Right. But it's not that big a space. And in that little amount of territory, there were really different problems.
Hey there pastors, are you feeling the weight of leadership? Do you crave a space where you can truly be yourself away from the demands of ministry? We understand that leading a church can be exhilarating, but it can also be exhausting and lonely. That's why we want to come alongside you as you encounter life. Welcome to EncounterLife for Pastors, a 12-week journey designed to offer you the high trust, high support small group experience you need. Each group consists of just four to six pastors, led by ECMC's Executive Director Amy Howard, a doctor of ministry candidate, and trained spiritual director, providing a confidential space for you to be known not just as a leader, but as a person. In your EncounterLife cohort, you can expect safe relationships, spiritual renewal.
Personal growth and accountability with grace. Each week, we'll ask two simple searching questions. What is God saying to me? What am I going to do about it? And the best part? You'll be surrounded by fellow pastors who truly understand the weight of leadership and our need for healing. Together, you'll walk this journey of transformation, reconnecting with your identity in Christ, and listening for God's voice again. EncounterLife for Pastors is more than a program. It's a space to heal, a place to be seen, a time to remember who you are. And whose you are. Space is limited and cohorts begin this summer and early fall. So if you're ready to encounter life and experience true transformation, visit encounterculturene dot com to learn more and join a cohort today. Because shepherds need shepherding too. You deserve this.
31:01Listening for Where the Spirit Groans
And my own experience, like being in those places in Africa, heightened my awareness of what's going on in the States. And I don't know if folks have traveled that much to different cities, but like every time I go to Washington, DC now, I lived there for five years and now I walk in and or and I just feel this like I tense up, but blood pressure goes up. It's this power, who do you know? You know, that kind of thing. I lived in LA for a little while and that was all like. Let's have fun. It was like an addiction to entertainment. I was in Vegas for like two hours and that was just dark. Just dark. So different places have and you've mentioned being close to Salem, Massachusetts, and holy cow, is that ever not a thing? And I think if you've been away from your space and then you come back in, you can see it in a different way.
So if you're looking to bring the good news to a people, not just the idea of the good news to sort of a corporate reality, but if you're looking to bring the good news, maybe it's really important to ask what is the good news for these people? What are what is liberation? What is wholeness? What what's stuck here? Right. So if I'm if I'm sharing the good news in Maine, in mid-Main. Right. Where we were for a long time. The good news did look a lot like freedom from addiction. Looked like healing the healing of bodies. And but if I'm maybe if I'm ministering in DC, the good news might be God has come to set you free from power structures and slavery and slavery to other people's opinion or whatever that is.
Or God loves you because of who you are, not because of who you know or things that. So really pressing your ear up against what the Lord is saying and what hurts in an area and what's stuck there. Right. So you kinda have to have enough distance to even know. So if I'm if I'm in Maine and I'm preaching largely to DC's problems, may not resonate. It may not resonate. Yeah. The founder of World Vision, his big statement that gets quoted throughout the organization, you may have heard this before too. It's God, may my heart be broken by the things that break the heart of God. May my heart be broken by the thing things that break the heart of God. And I think one of our prayers, our intercessory prayers, needs to be, God, what breaks your heart here?
Love that. I love that. Like entering into the groaning. What where's the Holy Spirit groaning here? Yeah. And finding those spaces and then p leaning into that, praying into that. Because you like you're describing the community across the river. Where where's that brokenness? Well, like why have they lost hope and beauty? And you know, goodness, Native Americans who you know are all about nature and cr yes, you know. Right. Loving the creation and yet they had lost that connection. Yeah. So like how do you how does God want to restore that? What does that look like for them? And that would look very different from Mid Maine and very different from DC.
Yeah. So listening attentively to where the pain is coming from. Jesus did seem to present the kingdom with different imagery to different groups of people and in different I mean, he had all sorts of different ways of understanding the good news showing up. Sometimes it was, you know, the good news is f is I you know, the kingdom of God is like a man who goes to search for one sheep. Like even you in the crowd of people, you matter to God. And he's not going to stop until he finds you. And to others, it's you know, a you know, imagery about agrarian imagery and things take time and they're slow and they may feel like it's happening too slowly, but the kingdom of God looks like this over here. Anyway, I always find that to be extremely fascinating. Can you just you touched on it a minute there? But the things that break God's heart and how our own hearts realize.
35:15Learning to Lament
Respond. We were talking even earlier today about learning lament. Can you can you say a little bit more about L lament is one of my biggest things. A lot of people say, you know, how can you believe in a good God if there's so much suffering in the world? And lament is the answer to that to me. And this is I don't want to sound bumper sticker or flip it because this is something I've had to deal with, you know, again, some of the worst environments in the world and you know, starving, children starving to death. They're like, In front of me that I've dealt with that level of suffering. And you know, I've I have my own physical suffering that I deal with every single day. But the opening up the language of lament in the especially the Psalms of Lament has just been so freeing to me. And that's something I learned from the African church, especially if there's a pastor in Nairobi that was a big influence on my life and part of my call story. And but he was talking about how
The American church, we like to skip lament. You know, we won't like to go from Palm Sunday to Easter Sunday and everything's great. We don't want to enter into that the depth of Holy Week, the horrible stuff there. And Lament Psalms literally like my favorite thing. If I could only have one part of the Bible, that's what it would be. And yay, lament. But the Lament psalms, my God, my God, why have you forsaken me? Yeah, out of the mouth of Jesus. That means we get to pray that. Like we get to question God. We get to ask the big questions. All lament psalms are directed straight to God. They all have like all but one have five specific characteristics. It's always directed to God. So this is not complaining about God.
This is talking right to him. Absolutely. So even in that, you're building your relationship with God. You're bringing that pain to God. And you're all you're saying, I don't get this. I'm mad about this. I'm really frustrated. But I know that you have something to say. But first I need to say my stuff. And so you're saying that counts. Yeah. Like that's real. Real prayer. That's real prayer. And Americans especially have lost that ability. 'Cause we kinda think we've gotten to a place of prayer once we're saying big, faith filled, hopeful things. If I'm a mature Christian, I don't have those sad days anymore. I just trust God. Everything will be fine. Let go and let God. Right. So if you look at the limits of so they first address God, then they complain. They just complain. Like, you know, my bones are drying up, the dogs have eaten, you know, other people. All my enemies are
Around me. Everybody's saying bad stuff about me. The wicked flourish and you know, here I am. And I mean they really Where the heck are you? Right. How long is this gonna take? I You didn't go out with my army. Did everything I was supposed to do and you didn't show up. And which of us have not lived that, right? My gosh. And then the third step is then a request like what do I really want you to do? What do I want what do I need God to do? And really specific stuff. And sometimes it's, you know, bless me because I'm a wretch, but other times it's smite the enemy. It's just take out.
Knock the tree down. Yeah. The ba the tree. Knock the bowak tree down, God. Right. The bowab drink. Right. And there can be some really pretty raw requests in there. And I love that because, you know, so many of us have things that we've always wanted to say, but it's not polite to God to say, you know, whatever. Yes. Say that again. Yeah. We feel like it's not polite to say, God, I demand, you know, like justice. I'm angry. I'm sad and I'm angry and I don't, I can't find you. I can't feel you. I can't see you in these circumstances. I can't tell you the number of times I we I have this idea somewhere. I don't know where I picked it up. I mean, I think it's in the air. Talk about regional stuff. I think it's in the air that if it's going well, that means God is blessing it.
Right. And if it's going poorly, God's hand is not on it. Right. Let's read Job together. Something wrong. Right. Now, the reality is sometimes our pain really is connected to our sin and our bad decisions or our immaturity and our immaturity. So there's humility in asking those questions. Absolutely. There's relevance to saying, God, there's stuff messed up with my body. Lord, what part of this conversation is mine? And there in the Psalms of Lament, there was repentance. God, I Against you and you only have I said Yes. Yes. But there also is a category for something else. And I think if you follow the logic, the broken logic of if it's going well, then God must be blessing it. And if it's going poorly, then I must be doing something wrong, or God doesn't like me, or whatever, then only then the wealthiest people in the world would be the ones who are the holiest.
Right. And newsflash. It's not always true. I mean I'm just gonna allow everyone to make a list in their own minds. Right. Just to kind of like solidify that. That logic doesn't make sense all the way to the end. Just because you have money and success. And in fact, sometimes I think quick success is its own kind of discipline. Yeah, exactly. 'Cause boy, is there a falls o so often after quick success. Yeah, and its own kind of suffering. Right. But that's just not the way we think. Right. We don't think I'm suffering, therefore the solution isn't just I'm doing something wrong. I need to fix something. It might be lament. My next move might be groaning before the
Yeah, exactly. Into relationship with God because He welcomes our groaning. Yeah. We don't have to get ourselves together and figure ourselves out in order to come to God. We need to bring God our groaning. And think of how often Jesus did that himself. I'm gardening Gethsemane. That's what that is. He is it is not blasphemy to stand before the Lord and say, Take this cup from me. Jesus entered into that completely. Yeah. So With the Psalms Limit. So you've got the address to God, you've got the complaint, you've got that request. And really raw, really honest. I did this exercise having a Sunday school class write their own one time. And I'm like, what do you want to request? We were writing a s a limit for persecuted Christians. And they're like, Bless them, comfort them. And I'm like, what do you really want to happen to their enemies? And they're like, you know, kill the enemy. I'm like, thank you. That's what
42:00The Turn in Every Lament
Right. Like, let's be really raw there. And then the thing that happens, if you read the Psalms of Lament, every one of them has a turn. There is this moment when the mood shifts. Twenty-two, Psalm 22 is really obvious. And it's like, what happened there? And my personal opinion is like sometimes there's gotta be like a month in between the request and the next. Yeah, absolutely. Like, so you've vented to God, and then the turn is. A remembering that God has been faithful in the past. It's like, Lord, I remember when I was able to go up to the temple. There, Lord, I remember when you brought us up out of Egypt. There's this moment of remembering. And that happened to me on my first again trip to Africa. I was in Ethiopia, and I got sick. I ate a sandwich at the Hilton Hotel. I was laid down for three days. Hood. Yeah, right. And I
I started writing a complaint. I mean, it was three, four or five pages of everything that I hated. Everything that I hated. And I ran out of steam after four or five pages. And then it was like it was like I'd wound up and then suddenly I started to unwind. And it was like, But God, thank you for this and thank you for that. And thank you for and it God just started bringing to my mind all of these ways that He had been faithful and you know, meeting these amazing Christians and Boy, Ethiopian coffee is something to write home about. And you know, just little things like that. But it was like remembering God's faithfulness. So that's part four of a of a regular lament psalm. And part five is then out of that remembrance of who God is, that's when you can say, and I will pr yet praise you. Yeah, absolutely. So all but one psalm ends in praise. And so that's how I survived in Africa and then through some really crazy, awful.
Making a choice. Ministry things now, as being able to enter into those laments. There was one time that I long story, but went through a really rough job situation, ended up leaving the place I had been in. And I my discipline was to write a lament psalm a day for a month. And just some of those were like just gray sadness and others were fury and anger. And but entering into that suffering, allowing the groanings of our hearts often you can write laments On behalf of someone else is really powerful. Yeah. To say, God, this is a broken thing and this person is being eaten alive by addiction or, you know, name the thing. And then, but putting your faith in God and when you go through that, entering into the pit, entering into the darkest stuff, the awful emotions and stuff, and then slowly seeing how God's been faithful and then coming out in praise, that transforms your relationship with God completely.
Wow, what a great idea. I love that you said the beginning to the distance between the beginning and the end of those four or five steps sometimes is a month and sometimes longer. I mean I the number of times and maybe this is just me, so I I'll just I'll just lay it all out there. So often my own lament, you know, starts with the anger and ends with it's not even a it's not even a A hundred percent. Now I feel good about this as I am remembering the good things. I'm actually still sad while I'm remembering the good things. I'm still angry. I'm saying I remember the time that I could feel your presence. I remember the moments where there were was breakthrough. And I don't feel those right now, but I'm at least gonna let that be the final word on this conversation. There was a time where I remembered those things and I will stand here waiting for the breakthrough. Right. I will.
Even if the breakthrough in my lifetime doesn't come, I will stand here and wait for it, even if the emotional resolution doesn't come. Yeah. Yeah. And some of the psalms, the praise isn't praise. It's a promise of praise. Like, Yeah. I know that you are able to do this. And when you do, then I will praise you. Not until then. And like you said earlier, like sometimes it's also a choice. There several psalms are like, why are you so downcast my soul? For I will yet praise him, my master and my God. And that is digging your heels into the solid rock when everything else is flailing and saying, I will yet praise him.
Yes. Yeah. I love, you know, surely I will praise the Lord. Like I will do this in the land of the living. That's my favorite little tagline. Like, God, I'm just gonna stand here and believe that maybe even someday while I'm still alive on this earth on this side of eternity, my heart again will rejoice. Right. Like this thing too, I'm leaving with faith with you. Right. For the ultimate conclusion of that. Wow. Wow. Wow. So can you just can we just bring this little bit full circle and just kinda so if you if you had some just some clear wisdom, What did you what were the just the highlights of what you felt like you could see that you've carried back home that you couldn't see when you were here?
47:17Trusting God When Plans Fall Apart
Yeah. What one is just a trust in God when crazy things happen. My brother recently said to me, it's not an adventure until things don't go according to plan. And in Africa everything doesn't go according to plan. Like every for instance, exactly, especially sick boys. So tr being able to trust God in the midst of that. And we mentioned early on that And parenting. My theory is that faith is faith is like a muscle and you have to exercise the muscle. Yeah. And in Africa, I saw how you have to exercise a the muscle all the time. Like that these folks, so many of them are just giants in the faith because they have to exercise the muscle of faith all the time. One time I was in Nairobi, this was more recently, trying to plan a trip, a mission trip, and I had a list of like 15 people I needed to meet.
But I didn't have a car and I didn't have a phone. And I didn't know how I was gonna get to all the people that I needed to meet. And I'm like, God, if this is of you, if you have this under hic under control, who knew? You know, I trust that you're gonna be able to work this out. And so the person I was sitting with was going by this place and she could drop me off to meet with this guy. And that was that was the start. And then well, this guy was. Meeting with that guy and I can I you know and then that guy was going to lunch with the other guy and it the whole day was like it was this beautiful choreography that God just put together like a ballet. It was unbelievable. And then I got stuck in an office for two hours with not it was again Nairobi Chapel was the min the church we were working with. I got stuck there for two hours with the woman who was their minister of prayer.
And darn it, what do you do when you hang out with a minister of prayer? You just pray. You know? And I it was honestly, this is part of a big part of my culture. Minister of prayer. Yeah, she was a rock star. I loved her. And after that two hours, I'm like, that's what I want to do. I wasn't a pastor at that point. I was working at a church. And at that point, it's like, I want to be a minister of prayer. Wow, Carolyn. So seeing God at work when things don't go according to plan was a huge lesson that I've seen over and over. Learning that faith was more like a push-up than like just sort of an instant light switch kind of dynamic. Right. Like that you were building muscle. I love that image that you chose to kind of exercise that muscle and anticipated that over time the muscle would grow.
Yeah. And when crazy things happen like COVID or, you know, all health problems. My mom is a pancreatic cancer survivor. I don't know if I told you that. But boy, that'll exercise your faith. Uh-huh. But when bad things happen, saying, I know that God is in here somewhere and I'm going to trust him. And when you've had those really hard situations before, that muscle's there and you can and you can say, Okay, God, I totally don't get this, but I know that you're gonna show up. Wow. Wow. Wow. Wow. Well, Carolyn, as we're kind of wrapping up, can I can I ask you just a couple more lighthearted questions? Okay. So just an easy one. Was there a moment on the field where you just had to laugh? Even in the middle of something totally unexpected or chaotic and it's a lot
Okay. Ha. I was telling your sons this story the other day. It's one of my favorite stories. I was I had been in Angola and was trying to just supposed to fly home through Europe and through Brussels. And I got to the airport and there were ten different checkpoints and it was just people harassing you and just everything was awful. And somewhere in the middle of that, I came to the ticket counter and the little guy that was helping with the baggage kept saying in Portuguese and yes, I have a little bit of Portuguese, he kept saying, I like your pen. That's a really nice pen. I like your pen. And I'm like, It's my only pen. Like, that's a really great pen. I like your pen. And finally I'm like, Fine, take my pen. So I handed him my pen and was like, Why did I do that? And then, you know, four or five more hassle checkpoints just to get to the international transit lounge. And then finally went down to my gate when it was time and somebody came up to me and said with a clipboard and said, Are you trying to fly to Brussels? I was like, Yes. And she said
Well, you can th that flight's been canceled. You can either stay in Luanda for three more days or you can fly to Lisbon. And I'm like, I can get home from Lisbon. Yeah. Like, whatever it takes. And she goes, Okay, look out there. There's this huge pile of bags. She's like, go find your bag and go get in that line. And I'm like, So I walk out the door and look at the pile of my bags and like, no way. And then I looked over kind of longingly at this line that was starting to form by the plane. And the very first person in line Was the guy with my pen with my bag saying, Mi amiga, mi amiga, and waving me over. It was the funniest thing. That was one of those moments that I just had to laugh. Cause boy, I was resentful about that pen. But that pen was the best investment I ever made. Like blessings be upon you, my friend. Wow. So wherever the pen guy is, I may God continue to give him a full life.
52:45Closing
And that's great. Well, Carolyn, this has just been such a blessing. It's just such a joy to hear your stories and I would love I have so many more things I would love to hear and love to share and I look forward to maybe talking again. Yeah. Sometime soon. Just hearing more. Thank you. Thanks for being here. Pleasure. Yeah. Thanks for your hospitality and your sourdough bread and your chickens. Amen. Well peace to all. Thank you for joining us on this episode of Between Heaven and Earth. We hope that you were stirred to curiosity and courage as we explored bringing heaven and earth together right where you are. Remember, you're not alone on this journey. We're here to support you in understanding what the Spirit of God is doing in your life and responding in obedience to his good leadership.
If you enjoyed today's conversation, please take a moment to like, share, subscribe, and leave a review. We'd love to hear from you. Share your thoughts and questions with us on our Facebook page or by email, podcast at encounterculturene.com. Your support helps us reach more people who are eager to join Jesus in his great project of restoration. Also, check out our website, encounterculturene.com for upcoming events and equipping opportunities for you and your church. Until next time, may you find joy living in between heaven and earth and the courage to bring them together wherever you go.